Mel Foster Insurance

Personal Insurance
Personal Insurance
Our Partners
Claims
Request A Quote
Glossary
FAQ
Our Team Members
Contact Us

Get a Quote

Claims

Personalized claims assistance available!

Our Claims Department is available Monday through Friday, 8am to 4:30pm. Stephanie Smith is the specialized claims contact and she can be reached during office hours at 1-800-383-5446 or email our Claims Specialist.

Unfortunately, accidents happen after hours. That’s why most of our companies are available 24 hours a day. Please check your insurance policy for claim reporting information. 

If you have Internet access, your company's website can guide you through the claim process. Just click on the company name to be directed to their website. 

For after hours, report claims directly to the company:

ACCIDENT FUND 866-206-5851
ACUITY 800-242-7666
ALLIED/NATIONWIDE 800-282-1446
ALLSTATE 800-255-7828
AUTO OWNERS 888-252-4626 (after hours 800-233-1131 (Flood))
CINCINNATI 513-870-2150
COLUMBIA 800-877-4245
CONTINENTAL WESTERN 866-232-6724
FOREMOST 800-527-3907
GREAT WEST 800-228-8040
HARLEYSVILLE 800-892-8877/888-453-0598 (Flood)
HASTINGS MUTUAL 800-442-8277
INDIANA INSURANCE 800-279-7221
INTEGRITY 800-348-1741
NATIONAL FLOOD 800-638-6620
NORTHLAND 800-328-5972
PROGRESSIVE 800-274-4499
SAFECO 800-332-3226
SECURA 800-318-2136/800-828-7047
SELECTIVE 866-455-9969
SENTRY 800-227-0201
SOCIETY 888-576-2438/800-945-7120
TRAVELERS 800-252-4633/800-238-6225
UNITED FIRE 800-343-9031
VICTORIA/TITAN 800-775-4642
WEST BEND 877-922-5246
ZURICH 800-987-3373